What's New

Business group divided over stance on ‘Lanes’ plan

Flagstaff Team

Chair threatens to quit amid split views on development stance

Debate over Peninsula Capital’s proposed development of up to eight storeys was shut down at the recent Devonport Business Association AGM, with the organisation’s chair threatening to resign.
Member Trevor Lawson had proposed a motion to clarify the association’s support for the Devonport Lanes development, tying it to a four-storey height limit – 13 metres rather than 27m.
“This motion does not ask us to oppose Devonport Lanes. It asks the opposite: that we publicly support it – enthusiastically – on one condition: that is it is built within the existing town-height limits,” Lawson said in a circular to members.


The motion, put by Lawson in general business, was seconded by member Lynn Lawton.
But confusion then erupted, with association chair Michael Moughan describing the motion as “politics” and saying he would resign if members supported it.
Moughan asked for those in favour and against. But Lawson said: “He declared the meeting closed – so fast that no member could realistically raise a hand.”
Lawson also said the chair denied him a right of reply.
He said the way the motion was handled is at variance with the board’s own constitution, which states members can bring matters up in general business.
He maintains the board’s support of the Peninsula Capital development is not neutral. It declares the DBA “sees clear potential business benefits” in the proposal and then acknowledges that the proposal “raises real questions… including around height, heritage, village character, timing, access, disruption and affected tenancies”.


But “it attaches no weight to any of them, and offers no association view on whether any of them are acceptable”.”
Lawton said regardless of his view on Peninsula Capital’s proposal, he felt Lawson’s motion should have been put and discussed by members. Standard AGM processes had not been followed, he said. Two people at the meeting had approached him afterwards, confused about what had gone on.
The chair had effectively hijacked the meeting, which was “totally wrong”, Lawton said.
The DBA “has the responsibility to hold a special meeting for the motion to be properly tabled,” Lawton said. Lawson has written to the 17DBA board seeking a special meeting.
Michael Moughan said: “I stand by what I said about resigning if the resolution was accepted. I volunteer to lead an association focused on its objects and practical results for members. I am happy to hear opposing views and have difficult conversations. I am not prepared to lead one where recurring process disputes dominate its time and culture, or where business is conducted in a disorderly way.
“While I am Chair, I will insist on proper consideration, notice and regard for the wider membership,” Moughan said


Several members discussed the resolution, including me, he said.
“Mr Lawson’s characterisation of what I said is incomplete and, in my view, misleading. Mr Lawson declined an invitation to speak. His request for a right of reply came after I had called the vote and it was apparent the resolution lacked support. Following his interjection, I called the vote again; the lack of support remained clear, and I declared it lost. Members were able to discuss and vote.
“Mr Lawson and Mr Lawton are now seeking to cast doubt on a result that went against them, Moughan said.


“My responsibility as Chair extends to the whole membership, including those who were not in the room. Our membership includes Peninsula Capital, tenants, business owners and others with a range of views on Devonport Lanes, which is why we need to be careful about presenting one position as the view of the whole DBA, and the process by which positions are adopted,” he said.
The board had conducted a survey to gauge members views, Moughan said
Lawson asked that the minutes reflect his account and requested a Special General Meeting, then taken the dispute to the media before the Board has considered his requests, Moughan said.
“He has again escalated a dispute before the process he requested has run its course. The Board will consider his correspondence, the draft minutes and the constitution.
“No decision has been made, and I will not pre-empt that process through the newspaper, Moughan said.


Overall BID manager Tabitha Coleman and the board had acheived much over the past year, he said.
“We have an exciting programme ahead. That is where I want our energy to go,” Moughan said.

Please consider supporting The Devonport Flagstaff by clicking here: